Flavor and Origin: Can They Coexist in One Cup?
A fair challenge from coffee purists: if you flavor a coffee, what happens to where it came from?
The respectful answer to a purist is to take the question seriously.
Summary
- Some coffee drinkers feel that flavoring hides origin, while others enjoy flavored coffee as a different category.
- We see two distinct goals, showing origin clearly in unflavored coffee and exploring flavor in separate products.
- Keeping the two clearly labeled is the key to honesty.
Key takeaways
- Different customers want different things.
- Clear labeling prevents confusion.
- Both can be done well, but not in the same cup.
Specialty coffee has a strong tradition of tasting origin. The goal is to notice what the soil, altitude, and processing contribute to the cup. For many people, flavoring is the opposite.
We take that view seriously. We also work on flavor. So how do the two fit?
The purist's concern
A strong flavoring can overpower the subtle notes of a good coffee. If the cup tastes of vanilla, you can no longer taste where the beans grew. For someone who values origin, that is a loss.
There is also a worry about masking defects. Flavoring has sometimes been used to cover poor-quality coffee. That history gives the practice a bad name.
The consumer's reality
Many people drink coffee with milk, sweetener, and syrups. They enjoy it that way. They are not wrong. Flavored coffee has a large and loyal audience around the world.
It is also true that many people begin with flavored drinks and later explore origin. Flavor can be a doorway.
Our approach
We think the honest answer is to keep them separate. We roast unflavored coffee with origin in mind. We also work, through our flavor projects, on products designed to be enjoyed as flavored coffee. The two are labeled clearly.
We do not use flavoring to hide weak coffee. We want to begin with good beans. See Roasting for Flavor, Roasting for Purity.
What the lab can do
In the laboratory we are building, we will test how flavors interact with different roasts and origins. Some coffees may support flavors better than others. Some may not support them at all. We expect to learn which. See Designing the Lab.
The role of Cremoras and Velsura
Our flavoring work connects with Cremoras and Velsura. These are part of how we are developing flavored products, which are still in development. We will talk about them in more detail when there is something specific to show.
Where we draw the line
We will not label a flavored coffee as single origin in a way that implies the flavor comes from the bean. We will not hide the presence of added flavor. We will not use a rare coffee only as a base for strong flavor.
A conversation, not a verdict
We do not expect to convince every purist. We hope they will see that we are trying to be honest and to respect both traditions.
Common questions
Will you flavor your best coffees?
We plan to keep our origin-focused coffees unflavored and develop flavored products separately.
Is flavored coffee lower quality?
It depends on how it is made. Flavoring can be done well or poorly, as with any craft.
Keep reading
Every piece is one of one.
Browse the specimen archive and acquire the piece that speaks to you. Each is catalogued once and sold once.