How Farmers Decide a Coffee Tree Is Done
Ask three coffee farmers when a tree is finished and you will get three answers. The decision is partly arithmetic and partly feeling.
A tree is done when keeping it costs more than replacing it, and not a day sooner or later.
Summary
- Farmers weigh yield, health, cost, and sentiment when deciding to remove a coffee tree.
- Many choose to delay renewal as long as possible.
- The roots of the trees that finally come out are what we turn.
Key takeaways
- The decision to remove a tree is rarely simple.
- Economics push toward renewal, while attachment pulls against it.
- Understanding this helps explain why old trees are rare.
When does a coffee farmer decide that a tree has to go? The answer is rarely clear.
The arithmetic
At its simplest, the decision is about yield. A tree that produces less each year earns less for the space it occupies. At some point, replacing it with a young tree makes financial sense, even though the young tree will take years to produce.
Farmers weigh the cost of new plants, labor, and lost income during the waiting years. For a small farm, that can be a hard calculation.
The health of the tree
A tree can also be removed because of disease, damage, or decay. Coffee leaf rust, pests, drought, or storms can leave a tree in poor shape. If it cannot recover, removal is the only option.
The delay
Because renewal is costly, many farmers put it off. They prune and fertilize and hope the tree will give another year or two. Some trees stay standing long after their best years.
That is part of why a few trees reach great ages. They survive not because they are cared for exceptionally, but because it has never seemed worth the trouble to pull them out.
The sentiment
There is also an emotional side. A farmer may remember planting a tree, or may have inherited it from a parent or grandparent. Pulling it out can feel like a loss. Some farmers keep old trees for that reason, even when they no longer pay.
I have heard farmers speak about particular trees with real affection. They are not just plants. They are part of the story of the land.
The conversation that started this
When we first started talking with neighbors about roots, many were surprised. They had always seen the old trees as a problem to be cleared. The idea that the wood might have value was new.
Some were skeptical. Others were intrigued. A few asked if they could help. It opened a conversation that is still going. See How We Work With Local Farmers and Woodworkers.
What it means for the supply
Because trees are removed so reluctantly, and so rarely at a great age, large old roots appear only occasionally. This is the underlying reason for scarcity in our work.
Common questions
Why do farmers keep old trees?
Because renewal is expensive and slow, and because some are attached to trees they or their families planted.
What decides when a tree is removed?
Usually declining yield, poor health, or the need to use the land for something else.
Keep reading
Every piece is one of one.
Browse the specimen archive and acquire the piece that speaks to you. Each is catalogued once and sold once.